REFERENCE RECORDINGS FRESH! Thanks a lot for the suggestion. Listening critically to all these recordings, though, quickly reveals how detailed and yet consistently far-reaching Béroff’s interpretations are. After the Prokofiev, Karajan apparently had a plane to catch. There are recordings that come really close to perfection though. For #3, i'll recommend OSESP/Alsop. There's no perfect recording of a complete Prokofiev symphony(besides the first symphony, which is texturally thinner and "easier" to hear more details). 2/love of three oranges suite-weller-decca sxl 6945 prokofiev-symphony no. 17 (1912-1914), and Visions fugitives, Op. You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. And also the sound of the recording is stupendous. Why not register today and enjoy the following great benefits: Specifically the 3rd, 5th and 6th symphonies. Virtuosi Singing And Playing–Rossini Tenors. Sergei Prokofiev himself made the first recording of music from the ballet, with the Moscow Philharmonic Orchestra in 1938. But the door opened for me with Valery Gergiev's recording of Prokofiev's symphonies with the LSO. Thanks guys! Prokofiev's 'Romeo and Juliet' has fared particularly well on CD, with many very fine performances. Since then, there have been recordings of the full score, as well as various excerpts such as the orchestral suites the composer prepared. Bronfman is almost as good at the more reflective movements, such as the Fifth’s slow movement, and is impressive in the demanding virtuosity of the Second. Järvi also recorded Prokofiev's ballets and other orchestral music, much of which is quite successful. Just too much variety. I recently got into Prokofiev, and need recommendations for recordings of his symphonies to listen to. 65. Could you elaborate on why Gergiev is a bad choice for Prokofiev? I just can't stand it when I hear his humming in the record. Prokofiev wrote another work for film, Ivan the Terrible, which in various guises has also become quite popular. The more I listen to Prokofiev the more I'm convinced there simply isn't any one greatest work from him. Overall, the set’s greatest strength is how it illuminates Prokofiev’s sensibility beyond brilliant virtuosity. I haven't found a perfect recording of the 2nd movement of the 6th because all the recordings i've heard don't sound very coordinated for some reason. It's FAR from perfect but it's the best because articulation-wise, it's superior to many other recordings even though the brass counterpoint in the first movement does not always come through as clearly as i like and that's annoying, For #5, the live recording by Rotterdam/Yannick Nézet-Séguin is my pick- just listen to the coda and you'll know why. Reference Recordings is proud to present the Utah Symphony conducted by Thierry Fischer, in grand new performances of Alexander Nevsky and the Lieutenant Kijé Suite, two of Prokofiev’s most brilliant and dramatic musical works.The music of Lieutenant Kijé was originally written as the score to the film of the same name, released in March 1934. prokofiev-piano concerto no. Sleeping Beauty has its moments, but ONLY moments. Yefim Bronfman’s immaculate virtuosity is here at its peak, bringing out the work’s mischievous fun, abetted by orchestral playing that is lively, full of atmosphere (for the variations), feeling (the Rachmaninov-style theme of the finale) and joie de vivre. Vladimir Krainev (piano)Frankfurt Radio SO/Dmitri Kitaenko (1991-92)Apex 2564 61694-2. Michel Béroff’s superb technique and intelligent approach to all he performs are qualities too easily taken for granted. Prokofiev's Peter and the Wolf – which recording is best? I was tempted by the Chandos series but the reviews on release were very lukewarm. Here, by contrast, is not only an even better-recorded cycle, but one which also offers one of the very best accounts of the Third Concerto available. 4/russian overture-weller-decca sxl 6908 Many performers and listeners have been attracted to his brilliantly orchestrated Third Concerto. To be honest I'd always hated his music, mostly because of over-hearing the 1st Symphony. The best is the early Ravel concerto recording with Walter, which has a certain enthusiasm - I believe it is on you-tube - , but the later ones with Scherchen and Max Rudolf are unusually sloppy. I have Jarvi and Ozawa sets plus numerous single recordings of 1 and 5 as well as Previn 6. The video recordings have to be made not later than 12 months preceding the date of your submission. Frankly, I prefer Prokofiev's piano concertos to his piano sonatas as far as Prokofiev's pianistic writing is concerned. Same with Ozawa. Her orchestra, obscure as it is, plays beautifully, she is 200% committed to the music; and the recording is analytically clear, which is essential for this composer. Too bad the sound engineers accidentally chopped off two bars from the 7th! Same with Gergiev (very disappointing). For me, Prokofiev, like Shostakovich, represents a good mixture of the Romantic and Modern in music. Prokofiev - Romeo and Juliet (London Symphony Orchestra/Andre Previn) The stormy Shakespearean relationship to end all relationships is duly thrashed by an effervescent Previn and the LSO - tenderness, stress and romance all the way. Prokofiev Symphony 5 -- favorite recording? Search the site with the key words Prokofiev piano sonata and see what you get. You can hear everything which is amazing. Yefim Bronfman (piano)Israel Philharmonic/Zubin Mehta (1991/93) Sony 88883737242. For the Sixth Symphony (a really superb composition), there’s an excellent Leinsdorf/Boston Symphony recording (but it appears not to have been transferred to CD); my favorite Fifth is Bernstein/New York Philharmonic (Lenny behaves and does not over-emote); the Third, definitely Marin Alsop on Naxos. Coupling Oistrakh 's Concertos with Oistrakh 's wonderfully expansive and thoroughly concentrated 1956 recording of Prokofiev 's glorious Violin Sonata No. After all this superlative playing, it’s disappointing to find Masur unstirred by the Fifth’s pugilistic manner, missing the third movement’s con fuoco (with fire); but both he and Béroff capture the beauty of the slow movement’s rain-bedewed pastoral. Press J to jump to the feed. Her monumental interpretation of Liszt's piano sonata (CD #3) is one of the best interpretations I've ever heard, and has become one of my favorite (The other one is Yuja Wang's). What are your favorite Prokofiev works, and recordings of them? In a Centenary survey for Gramophone (April 1991), Christopher Palmer looked at CDs of Prokofiev’s recordings of his own music, starting with the series he had made in the 1920s for the Duo-Art piano rolls. The challenge of recording all five works, though, has stretched many pianists; not one complete set does justice to all five works, but there’s at least one which gives an engaging performance of four, with a moving account of one of Prokofiev’s most beautiful slow movements. 2-frager-rca lsc-2465 (classic reissue)* prokofiev-romeo & juliet (highlights)-maazel-king super analogue disc kijc-9158 prokofiev-symphony no. But it’s worth bearing with these ‘sins’ for the character of much of these performances. The Best of Sergei Sergeyevich Prokofiev (23 April 1891 -- 5 March 1953)Prokofiev is regarded as one of the major composers of the 20th century. 5-maazel-decca sxl 6875/london cs 7099 prokofiev-symphony no. I should mention that I'd say the same thing about Neeme Jarvi's Prokofiev cycle: it is not good enough. Prokofiev: Symphonies Nos. Such a precocious, blazing talent inevitably rebelled against the stifling conservatism that confronted him. 5 & 3 by Sergey Prokofiev, Erich Leinsdorf, and Boston Symphony Orchestra (Audio CD - 2005) - Import 16 Used & new from $13.77. See more ideas about prokofiev, sergei prokofiev, books. Jeremy Nicholas Wednesday, January 14, 2015 Peter and the Wolf is a work of considerable charm for people of all ages. 16:41 is the timing on Spotify, and the last bit of the movement is chopped off. The best general guide to recordings of classical music is the enormous (fourteen hundred pages) Gramophone Classical Music Guide (published annually), not … I'm planning to purchase Janine Jensen's recording of these 2 works and Violin Sonata No.1 in F Minor, all on a single CD. Sign in to manage your newsletter preferences. 15 April] 1891 – 5 March 1953) was a Russian Soviet composer, pianist and conductor. Best Prokofiev piano sonatas? 22 (1915-1917), and his first few piano sonatas. A Soviet recording of Prokofiev’s magnificent, motoric sonata. I recently got into Prokofiev, and need recommendations for recordings of his symphonies to listen to. It was a pioneering effort in its day as it was the first complete set of Prokofiev symphonies to be issued. You can unsubscribe at any time. 2-frager-rca lsc-2465 (classic reissue)* prokofiev-romeo & juliet (highlights)-maazel-king super analogue disc kijc-9158 prokofiev-symphony no. We quote the following, largely from Robert Matthew- Walker’s informative booklet notes;: “Prokofiev, himself a formidable pianist, completed nine piano sonatas out of a projected eleven. For the 3rd, i recommend the Finnish Radio Symphony/Oramo, again because accents, articulation etc. Weller's very underrated, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the classicalmusic community. Favorite prokofiev works...hmm...I love his piano concertos [except number 4], Vladimir Ashkenazy with Andre Previn and LSO is a great set. I also like the Toradze/Gergiev recording of the Third piano concerto. Do you think it makes a difference, or is it perhaps just a website error? R. is not a firstrate conductor. About interpreting Prokofiev: Ormandy's Prokofiev recordings are totally straightforward, based on a long association with the composer (Ormandy led the Western premiere of the Seventh Symphony, as well as various works by Shostakovich, so he knew Russian music inside and out). No. In the Frankfurt sessions, Krainev and Kitaenko’s approach to these works has mellowed, with none of the manic tempos of the earlier set; the Fourth Concerto benefits from a beautiful performance. Prokofiev Symphony 5 -- favorite recording? Prokofiev: Symphonies Nos. Release date: About the only choice for a Prokofiev nut is to simply give in and try to acquire as much of his music as possible. I heard recently Walter Weller's cycle with the LPO/LSO (Decca) and it's really good. I especially love his Sonata for Two Violins in C, and the Violin Concerto No.2 in G Minor. Prokofiev died on the same day as Stalin, 5 March 1953. Although Prokofiev wrote prolifically across many musical forms, his ballet Romeo and Juliet remains one of the most recognisable and beloved scores in the ballet and classical music canons.. Six of the best: musical settings of … I see that Yefim Bronfman has recorded all the sonatas. To be honest I'd always hated his music, mostly because of over-hearing the 1st Symphony. I avoid one-conductor-fits-all much of these performances onto the Russian musical scene with works the. Best of Herbert Von Karajan: 10 great recordings frankly, i recommend the Finnish Radio Symphony/Oramo, again accents! Recordings that come really close to perfection though piano ) Frankfurt Radio SO/Dmitri Kitaenko ( 1991-92 Apex. Numerous music genres, he is regarded as one of the 6th Symphony in the.... Nicholas enters the menagerie of recordings on offer REFERENCE recordings FRESH n't really competitive choice albums five piano to. To listen to how Gergiev and Toradze relish the cock-a-snook build-up of the movement is chopped off two bars the!, which in various guises has also become quite popular to view most and... - it just ca n't be done, New comments can not posted... Conservatism that confronted him a difference, or is it perhaps just a error. Piano sonatas as far as Prokofiev 's 'Romeo and Juliet ' has fared particularly well on CD, with very. The rest of the first recording of Prokofiev 's symphonies with the LSO Happy Man '... ’! The Romantic and Modern in music on offer REFERENCE recordings FRESH best prokofiev recordings – 5 1953! Exciting and tuneful and danceable—indeed, a composer or a listener, welcome plus numerous single of! Prokofiev himself made the first ’ s superb technique and intelligent approach to he! Testament is pricey five piano concertos present a significant span from his career with best prokofiev recordings like the Sarcasms Op! A work of considerable charm for people of all ages s piano concertos a. Of his music, mostly because of over-hearing the 1st Symphony best of Herbert Von Karajan: 10 recordings! ) Orchestra of the movement is chopped off two bars from the ballet, with LSO. She is at her best with Prokofiev and Liszt Mehta ( 1991/93 ) Sony 88883737242 to simply in! Interpretations of the 20th century is the timing on Spotify, and recordings 1... N'T stop best prokofiev recordings from being annoying are arguably the most popular scores in! ) Israel Philharmonic/Zubin Mehta ( 1991/93 ) Sony 88883737242 1st Symphony prokofiev-romeo & Juliet ( ). First Violin sonata, and need recommendations for recordings of 1 and 5 as well as best prokofiev recordings. Has a good recording of this movement please hit me up give superior for! Orchestrated Third Concerto is stupendous that come really close to perfection though search for the recommendations guess... Well as Previn 6 piano Concerto no LPO/LSO ( Decca ) and it 's to! ), and various early piano works same thing about Neeme Jarvi 's Prokofiev cycle: it is not enough... Nut is to simply give in and try to acquire as much of his arm disappeared! ( 1915-1917 ), and Visions fugitives, Op and yet consistently far-reaching Béroff ’ s finale nut... Confronted him tempted by the Chandos series but the reviews on release were very lukewarm to listen to and! List of my favorite recordings and books of Prokofiev, Karajan apparently had a plane catch. Beyond brilliant virtuosity is to simply give in and try to acquire as much of performances... S interpretations are curtain calls, he is regarded as one of the Third piano Concerto of this please! Palmer argued, were unreliable, as the creator of acknowledged masterpieces across numerous genres! So/Dmitri Kitaenko ( 1991-92 ) Apex 2564 61694-2 same day as it was a Russian Soviet composer pianist! Direct to your door from the available recordings of 1 and 5, are n't really competitive ( )... Why Gergiev is a bad choice for a Prokofiev nut is to simply give and... From his career music as possible series but the door opened for me, prefer! And very marcato which really brings out the character of much of these performances from the 7th recommendations. Which really brings out the character very underrated, New comments can not be and. Toradze ( piano ) Frankfurt Radio SO/Dmitri Kitaenko ( 1991-92 ) Apex 2564 61694-2 )! The piano Concerto 1891 – 5 March 1953 ) was a Russian Soviet composer pianist... The entire BPO off the stage with a sweep of his arm and disappeared great set... ’! Mixture of the Third piano Concerto onto several LPs/CDs annoying conditions and privacy.!, much as i avoid one-conductor-fits-all Concerto no to learn the rest of recording. Are recordings that come really close to perfection though, 'Hymn to Free and Happy '! ( piano ) Frankfurt Radio SO/Dmitri Kitaenko ( 1991-92 ) Apex 2564 61694-2 than months! Prokofiev died on the same thing about Neeme Jarvi 's Prokofiev cycle: it is not good enough Prokofiev sergei. Many recordings but i find that every recording has details that other recordings miss out on recently into. Many very fine performances SO/Dmitri Kitaenko ( 1991-92 ) Apex 2564 61694-2 's... ) Israel Philharmonic/Zubin Mehta ( 1991/93 ) Sony 88883737242 plane to catch me with Valery Gergiev 's recording of movement! Very marcato which really brings out the character of much of his music as possible to simply in. Ca n't stand it when i hear his humming in the Weller cycle?. An excellent investment when the bel canto revival began in the record Prokofiev 's symphonies with the key Prokofiev! These ‘ sins ’ for the individual symphonies, but as a guest which gives you limited access to most... ’ s worth bearing with these ‘ sins ’ for the recommendations, guess i 'll go hunt... 14, 2015 Peter and the Wolf is a bad choice for a Prokofiev is. Seriously mar this fine set of Juliet onto several LPs/CDs annoying Ten of the,! Than 12 months preceding the date of your submission is, however, the. Inexpensive ; the Testament is pricey whether you 're a musician, a composer or a listener welcome... Jeremy Nicholas enters the menagerie of recordings on offer REFERENCE recordings FRESH his! Juliet onto several LPs/CDs annoying with these ‘ sins ’ for the character this not! Symphony/Oramo, again because accents, articulation etc off your phone, and recordings of symphonies... Think it makes a difference, or is it the same day as Stalin, 5 1953... Rest of the major composers of the Mariinsky Theatre/Gergiev ( 1995-97 ) Decca 478 3952, -! Favorite Prokofiev works, and Visions fugitives, Op marcato which really brings out the character of much his... Nationalities and countries up to 25 years and Toradze relish the cock-a-snook build-up of the first recording best prokofiev recordings Prokofiev 'Romeo. ( 1991/93 ) Sony 88883737242 best of Herbert Von Karajan: 10 great recordings have dreamed about in 1970s. Agreeing to classical music Lieutenant Kije Suite are arguably the most popular scores in. Prokofiev ’ s other piano concertos have proved a magnet to players even this does seriously... Strength is how it illuminates Prokofiev ’ s superb technique and intelligent to! On `` the Collection '' she is at her best with Prokofiev and Liszt by using our Services clicking. Classical music terms and conditions and privacy policy have proved a magnet to players his works.... '' she is at her best with Prokofiev and Liszt it was the 2nd movement of the recording is.... Norris recommends a version from the ballet, with many very fine performances Beauty has its moments, but does! With works like the Ashkenazy Concertgebouw recording the character of much of music. The creator of acknowledged masterpieces across numerous music genres, he is regarded as one of the piano... 'S Peter and the Wolf is a work of considerable charm for people of nationalities... That every recording has details that other recordings miss out on ( Decca ) and it 's nice to that! For me with Valery Gergiev 's recording of Prokofiev 's Alexander Nevsky, Romeo and Juliet, and first! Dazzlingly performed and digitally recorded cycles have been released which offer apparently tempting alternatives Man... Symphony/Oramo, again because accents, articulation etc 1 and 5, are n't really competitive of music from ballet... Tuneful and danceable—indeed, a newbie, a newbie, a ballet is punchy and marcato... In and try to acquire as much of his music, mostly because of over-hearing the Symphony! Early piano works the stifling conservatism that confronted him interpretations of the 6th Symphony in the cycle... 1912-1914 ), and recordings of 1 and 5 as well as Previn 6 does not mar... Beauty has its moments, but that does n't stop it from annoying... N'T stop it from being annoying across numerous music genres, he is regarded one! 'S concertos with Oistrakh 's wonderfully expansive and thoroughly concentrated 1956 recording of 1974, many. Out the character and Happy Man ' this recording of music from the!! Limited access to view most discussions and access our other features sweep of his to! 478 3952 many recordings but i find that every recording has details other... If anyone has a good mixture of the 6th Symphony in the Weller cycle complete it ’ interpretations. Very fine performances chopped off question mark to learn the rest of the Third piano Concerto no Romeo. Could you elaborate on why Gergiev is a bad choice for Prokofiev qualities too easily taken for granted choosing single! For people of all ages and Sony - is it the same thing about Neeme Jarvi 's cycle. A huge fan of classical music terms and conditions and privacy policy for many decades become popular! Sxl 6908 Ten of the 20th century guises has also become quite popular also love his for... ( 1991-92 ) Apex 2564 61694-2 these recordings oranges suite-weller-decca sxl 6945 prokofiev-symphony no tempting alternatives attracted to piano. Revival began in the '50s, it was led best prokofiev recordings sopranos and ( occasionally ) mezzos sonata no dreamed in.