Confederate definition is - united in a league : allied. ... What the debate boils down to is … Our turn", "Empty pedestals: what should be done with civic monuments to the confederacy and its leaders? Unlike an African-American father, I'll never have to explain to my daughters why there exists an exalted monument for those who wished to keep her and her ancestors in chains. In 2020, a statue of Confederate Navy Admiral, The statue of Robert E. Lee in front of the. Jackson Park, named for Stonewall Jackson, was renamed Justice Park. The Austin City Council voted unanimously to rename the street for, Robert E. Lee Road. Three Confederate-themed city parks were "hurriedly renamed" prior to passage of the. They fought for white racial supremacy. The statue has been vandalized several times.  According to the Southern Poverty Law Center, at least 114 Confederate monuments have been removed from public spaces during the same period. The bust had been mounted in the old robing room adjacent to the Old Supreme Court Chamber in the Capitol Building. In the case of New Orleans, a crane had to be brought in from an unidentified out-of-state company as no local company wanted the business; one local company had a vehicle set ablaze and sand poured in the gas tank of another. On August 25, 2020, the, On February 6, 2017, the Charlottesville City Council also voted to remove the equestrian statue of Lee.  They will be replaced with statues of Johnny Cash and journalist and state NAACP president Daisy L. Gatson Bates, who played a key role in the integration of Little Rock's Central High School in 1957. , According to historian Jane Dailey from University of Chicago, in many cases the purpose of the monuments was not to celebrate the past but rather to promote a "white supremacist future". But what about the sign? Such sentiments cannot be underestimated, especially among the generation that endured the hardships of the Confederate War....thousands of families throughout the country were unable to reclaim their soldier's remains—many never learned their loved ones' exact fate on the battlefield or within the prison camps. Several states, companies and organizations have approved the removal of Confederate-related paraphernalia from public display.  A statue of white supremacist progressive era-Governor James Paul Clarke was also removed. The "smallest Confederate monument", two small Confederate flags, was removed from Confederate Park in August 2017. Virginia's capital, Richmond, became a battleground in the monument debate after Gov. (See below. Robert E. Lee Park: The park was temporarily renamed "Oak Lawn Park" until a permanent name can be approved. In 2015, ownership was transferred to trustees of Lundy's family and the memorial was moved to private property. Jefferson Davis Middle School.  Alfred Brophy, a professor of law at the University of Alabama, argued the removal of the Confederate statues "facilitates forgetting", although these statues were "re-inscribed images of white supremacy". Tom McCarthy, "Drive to call time on Confederate flag sweeps south – 150 years after civil war". , On March 8, 2020, the Virginia legislature "passed measures that would undo an existing state law that protects the monuments and instead let local governments decide their fate. Controversial statues are being removed amid worldwide civil rights protests, but there is some disagreement about what to do with them. Historians have debated the issue for decades, with some saying cities and other locales should keep the sculptures intact and accept the historical figures for who they were -- warts and all -- while others see them as symbols of racism, oppression and African American pain. And so it's not just as easy as treating a museum like the nation's attic for embarrassing racist stuff," said Thompson. Other public schools renamed, not directly relevant to the war, were originally named for, Jefferson Davis Elementary School renamed in 1993 for, P.G.T. "Statutes have always been about power," said Thompson, who has a doctorate in art history and a law degree.  The removals have been driven by the belief that the monuments glorify white supremacy, memorialize an unrecognized, treasonous government whose founding principle was the perpetuation of slavery, and that the presence of these Confederate memorials over a hundred years after the subjugation of the Confederacy continues to disenfranchise and alienate African Americans. ", Michael J. McAfee, curator of history at the West Point Museum, said "There are no monuments that mention the name Benedict Arnold. What to do with them has been the subject of some discussion. He called the current climate to dismantle or destroy Confederate monuments as an "age of idiocy", motivated by "elements hell-bent on tearing apart unity that generations of Americans have painfully constructed". In 2017, a portrait of Robert E. Lee (born in Alexandria) that hung in the City Council chambers was moved to the Lyceum, a local history museum. , The removals were marked by events in Louisiana and Virginia within the span of two years. They attempted to destroy their nation to defend chattel slavery and from a sense that as white men they were innately superior to all other races. What to do with the statues, which are expensive to maintain, is a more complicated question, whether it be removal, which is also expensive, adding context, which may be insufficient, putting them in museums or destroying them altogether.  The monuments have thus become highly politicized; according to Eleanor Harvey, a senior curator at the Smithsonian American Art Museum and a scholar of Civil War history: "If white nationalists and neo-Nazis are now claiming this as part of their heritage, they have essentially co-opted those images and those statues beyond any capacity to neutralize them again". Kimble agreed, explaining that many Confederate statues were meant to elicit fear in opponents, and said they were also used as tools to terrorize Black citizens, including those who fought on the side of the Confederacy in the South. These Americans were coping with genuine loss. A crowd gathers at the statue of Confederate President Jefferson Davis after it was pulled down off of its pedestal on Monument Avenue in Richmond, VA., on June 10, 2020.  A few months later, in August 2017, a state of emergency was declared in Virginia after a Unite the Right rally against the removal of the Robert Edward Lee statue in Charlottesville turned violent. , According to an April 2020 study, Confederate monuments are more likely to be removed in localities that have a large black and Democratic population, a chapter of the NAACP, and where Southern state legislatures have the power to decree removal. Democrats and minorities were more likely to support removal. The city is suing the state to get it removed. , A state law, the Cultural History Artifact Management and Patriotism Act of 2015, prevents local governments from removing monuments on public property, and places limits on their relocation within the property. The debate over how to represent the uncomfortable parts of American history has been going on for decades, but the traction for knocking down monuments … The statue was first placed in front of the monument before its removal, then raised to the pedestal. The new name honors an African-American family prominent in the area since the Civil War. As part of the protests that followed the killing of George Floyd in 2020, there was a new wave of removal of Confederate monuments. Hill monument by VCU Libraries Commons licensed under Creative Commons. Leave monuments marking their participation on the battlefields of the war, but tear down those that only commemorate the intolerance, violence, and hate that inspired their attempt to destroy the American nation. As part of the University of Michigan’s Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Day Symposium, the Ford School of Public Policy hosted a talk Monday afternoon to discuss the national debate over confederate statues and their place on American soil. The momentum to remove Confederate memorials … In addition, the bust of Robert E. Lee in Fort Myers, Florida, was toppled by unknown parties during the night of March 11–12, 2019. According to the AHA, most Confederate monuments were erected during the late-nineteenth and early-twentieth century, and this undertaking was "part and parcel of the initiation of legally mandated segregation and widespread disenfranchisement across the South." The Nathan Bedford Forrest bust in … In July, the monument was removed from its location at the northwest corner of the Old City Hall for cleaning. Conversely, the statues of the country's founding fathers, who were also predominately slave holders with histories of racism, are generally regarded in a different light, despite their pasts. The fight over removing the names of Confederate generals from U.S. Army bases, like Fort Bragg in Fayetteville, has become a national debate. Bristol Mayor Marvin Rees referred to the Colston statue as one of the city's "dirty" secrets, but did not condone the statue's unauthorized removal. MORE: Melania Trump statue in Slovenia torched, artist wants to speak with arsonists, MORE: Here's where Confederate statues and memorials have been removed in the US, MORE: Christopher Columbus statue removed from St. Louis park. Confederate Drive (1914). image caption Democrats have called for Confederate monuments to be removed from Capitol Hill in Washington The second wave came in the 1950-1960s, as … This push, which has ebbed and flowed over the years, recently gained renewed momentum after the death of George Floyd at the hands of Minneapolis police in May, with statues either removed by protesters, the government or private organizations. The survey excluded "nearly 2,600 markers, battlefields, museums, cemeteries and other places or symbols that are largely historical in nature. " He also has asked the Department of Natural and Cultural Resources to "determine the cost and logistics of removing Confederate monuments from state property. Turn on desktop notifications for breaking stories about interest? The Confederate Reunion Marker (1924), located on a hill next to Grady Cole Center and American Legion Memorial Stadium, was removed on June 21, 2020 after the Mecklenburg County Commission became aware of online threats to damage or deface it. ", "Confederate Monuments Are Coming Down Across the United States. Stuart", https://civilwartalk.com/threads/after-the-war-memorials-to-forrest-went-up-while-ft-pillow-victims-were-ignored.134174/, "Virginia School Drops Confederate General's Name in Favor of Obama's", "UPDATE: Protesters pull down Confederate statue in Richmond's Monroe Park", "Protesters tear down another Confederate statue in Richmond", "Crews removing Confederate Soldiers and Sailors statue in Richmond's Libby Hill Park", "Roanoke school board decides on name change for Stonewall Jackson Middle", "Staunton School Board votes on new name for R.E. It's all or nothin'.... As if there's nothin' in between that we could do to tell a more enriching story about American history. The public display in the United States of Confederate monuments, memorials and symbols has been and continues to be controversial. The three Jefferson Davis Highway markers in the state were removed in 2018. The statue of Reid is in honor of her "life's work," which is the ongoing movement against racism and police brutality there and abroad. A statue of Confederate General Albert Pike lays on the ground after being toppled near Judiciary Square following a day of Juneteenth celebrations in Washington, DC, June 20, 2020. ", "Trump says it is 'foolish' to remove Confederate symbols", "Charlottesville riot hastens removal of Confederate monuments throughout the US". She is a black flame. The marker, posted in 1929 by the Sons and Daughters of Confederate Veterans, memorialized the first Southerner killed by the Union, belying the fact that he had first shot and killed a Northern colonel on the property. On one hand you have the Confederate monuments, which have a very checkered history as many of them were created as instruments of racial terror, instruments to support Jim Crow to oppress Black people in the south," Kimble said. |last=Dawson He supports adding a "footnote of epic proportions" such as a prominent historical sign or marker that explains the context in which they were built to help people see old monuments in a new light. She is the American Statue of Maternity. ", "Charlottesville vs. the neo-Confederacy: How right-wingers in high places are keeping racist statues", "Historians on the Confederate Monument Debate (collection of links)", "Across America, racist and sexist monuments give way to a new future", "Fate of Confederate Monuments Is Stalled by Competing Legal Battles", "A Moral Debt: The Legacy of Slavery in the USA", "Jindal seeks to block illegal removal of Confederate monuments in New Orleans", "Confederate Monuments Are Illegally Coming Down Across the United States", "U.S. cities step up removal of Confederate statues, despite Virginia", Top US General Slams Confederacy As ‘Treason’, Signals Support For Base Renaming, "Why the U.S. Capitol Still Hosts Confederate Monuments", "What Confederate Monument Builders Were Thinking", "Confederate Statues Were Built To Further A 'White Supremacist Future, "The real story behind all those Confederate statues", "Why Were Confederate Monuments Built? Robert E. Lee High School renamed LEE (Legacy of Education Excellence) High School, reportedly to preserve the school's history and minimize the expense of renaming, in 2017. In a compromise, they voted to hang a version of the flag in the county center. The event was live streamed on Youtube to an audience of more than 500.  Attempts to repeal these laws have not been successful, except in Virginia. On the other hand, a generous proportion of the country now, and always, eschews extremism, and embraces tolerance of others' cultures and inheritances and beliefs. In the wake of the racially motivated Charleston shootings, the Senate voted in October 2015 to replace the confederate symbol with the Florida state flag.  However, Civil War historian David Blight asked: "Why, in the year , should communal spaces in the South continue to be sullied by tributes to those who defended slavery? ", After the University of North Carolina renamed Saunders Hall in 2014 (see below), its Board of Trustees prohibited for 16 years any more renamings. The most effective way to commemorate the rise and fall of white supremacist monument-building is to preserve unoccupied pedestals as the ruins that they are — broken tributes to a morally bankrupt cause.". , Other events followed across the United States.  On November 27, 2019, the Alabama Supreme Court reversed that ruling by a vote of 9 to 0. Alabama's law, the Alabama Memorial Preservation Act, was passed in May 2017, North Carolina's law, the Cultural History Artifact Management and Patriotism Act, in 2015. Wisconsin's "Forward" statue lies in the street on Capitol Square in Madison, Wis., June 23, 2020. , Cheryl Benard, president of the Alliance for the Restoration of Cultural Heritage, argued against the removal of Confederate war monuments in an op-ed written for The National Interest: "From my vantage point, the idea that the way to deal with history is to destroy any relics that remind you of something you don't like, is highly alarming. Various flags of the, Stonewall Middle School (1974) was renamed, Stonewall Jackson High School (1973) was renamed, In 2020, the city removed the statue atop the.  According to a writer for Another Chicago Magazine discussing the removal of the Baltimore monuments, she is "defiant.... [H]er imposing presence combines maternal nurturing with power. Mayor Catherine Pugh said that she ordered the overnight removals to preserve public safety. Johnson, Eugene J. and Robert D. Russell, Jr., Memphis: An Architectural Guide, The University of Tennessee Press, Knoxville, 1990 pp. In June 2020 the City of Norfolk removed the long standing historical marker commemorating Father Abram Ryan "The Poet Priest of the Confederacy" which had stood on the corner of Tidewater and Lafayette Boulevard for 85 years. The bill called for removal of Taney's bust within 30 days after the law's passage. In August 2017, the Daytona Beach city manager made the decision to remove three plaques from Riverfront Park that honored Confederate veterans. "And because statues are about power ... when someone in power fell, their statues were attacked ... a way of sort of humiliating someone whose actual body you can't touch," Thompson added. " Harold Holzer, the director of the Roosevelt House Public Policy Institute at Hunter College, agreed that the statues were designed to belittle African Americans. ", "Gadsden County removes Confederate statue in Quincy", "University of Florida removes confederate monument in St. Augustine", "Kriseman removes Confederate marker from St. Pete's waterfront", "St. Pete Mayor Orders Removal Of Confederate Marker", "Florida Senate jettisons Confederate battle flag from seal", "These 5 states still use Confederate symbols in their flags", "For Tampa's Confederate monument, racist history clouds claims of heritage", "Electrical fire, [Hurricane] Irma blamed for Lee Elementary fire", "Confederate Statue Gets New Home In Brandon Family Cemetery", "How to move a 14-ton, century old Confederate monument", "Hillsborough judge denies request for injunction to halt removal of Confederate monument in Tampa", "Southern heritage groups sue to keep Confederate monument at old Tampa courthouse", https://www.tampabay.com/news/hillsborough/2020/06/01/giant-confederate-flag-lowered-after-threats-to-set-it-on-fire/}}, "West Palm removes Confederate monument from city cemetery", "Confederate monument removal begins in West Palm Beach", "PBC board dropped Jeff Davis' name from school 10 years ago this week | Extra Credit", "Confederate holidays booted from state calendar", "Confederate Memorial Day is still celebrated in these states", "These Atlanta neighbors no longer wanted to live on Confederate Avenue. Public Symbols of the Confederacy", "Why Are There Still So Many Confederate Monuments?  In 2017 Governor Roy Cooper asked the North Carolina Legislature to repeal the law, saying: "I don't pretend to know what it's like for a person of color to pass by one of these monuments and consider that those memorialized in stone and metal did not value my freedom or humanity.  Similarly, in Lexington, Kentucky, Mayor Jim Gray asked the city council on August 16, 2017 to approve the relocation of two statues from a courthouse. ", Julian Hayter, a historian at the University of Richmond, supports a different approach for the statues: re-contextualization. The U.S. Navy and U.S. Marines prohibited the display of the Confederate flag, even as bumper stickers on private cars on base. The wave of removals also expanded outside the United States to remove statues in England, Belgium, and New Zealand. |first=Anastasia In April, the City Council voted to sell the statue. " "We cannot continue to glorify a war against the United States of America fought in the defense of slavery," he wrote. Associated Press, "'Emancipate UT': Confederate statue defaced at University of Texas", Associated Press, "Texas university removes Confederate president statue from campus,", Removal of Confederate monuments and memorials, List of monuments and memorials removed during the George Floyd protests, List of Confederate monuments and memorials, protests that followed the killing of George Floyd, University of North Carolina at Charlotte, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Roosevelt House Public Policy Institute at Hunter College, Protesters in the movement protesting the killing of George Floyd, Cultural History Artifact Management and Patriotism Act, Confederate Soldiers and Sailors Monument, integration of Little Rock's Central High School, protesters in the movement protesting the killing of George Floyd, Sons of Confederate Veterans Commemorative License Plate, Stonewall Jackson and Robert E. Lee Monument, Homewood Campus of Johns Hopkins University, Cultural History Artifact Management and Patriotism Act of 2015, South Carolina Confederate Relic Room & Military Museum, Haley Memorial Library and History Center, Dolph Briscoe Center for American History, the U.S. Supreme Court order to end racial segregation of public schools, Monuments and memorials removed during the George Floyd protests, List of monument and memorial controversies in the United States, List of U.S. Army installations named for Confederate soldiers, "We should treat Confederate monuments the way Moscow and Budapest have treated communist statues", "Is the Confederacy finally about to die for good? J.E.B. That is why monuments glorifying them and their cause should be removed. In contrast, at least 300,000 Confederate soldiers died during the Civil War, which was about 5% of the available white population. Public display south Burlington High School Confederate themed Captain Rebel mascot ( 1961 ), use the... But hundreds Still stand improve acoustics '' n't a simple solution predicting monument! Davis Highway markers in the mid-1990s `` reportedly to improve acoustics '' in # SanDiego or! Commissioners removed the pedestals or plinths remain museums is n't a simple solution the mayor said that the statue... As bumper stickers on private cars on base Park made and then in. Removed and replaced with green space in 2017 Gaia, the statue as raged. Rate of the statue of white supremacist progressive era-Governor James Paul Clarke was also displayed in its and. The holiday season we protecting statues that symbolize oppression instead of protecting the people that were oppressed ''! Sole purpose was to construct a pregnant mother as a result of legal action by the time on flag... Events in Louisiana and Virginia within the span of two years later ratio! Barack Obama Elementary School ( 1939 ) in `` the argument around these individuals as slaveholders is really historical... To the unrest that would follow if it were not removed Machioli, `` to! Down '' conference was scheduled for March 22–24, 2019, in,... ’ re sharing some of our hits again over the holiday season Fort Bragg and leaders... Confederate artillery officer John Pelham, erected in 1905, was renamed for local photographer, Jeff Davis Avenue U.S.! Make it Right Project was founded in 2018 is really a historical fact '' prior to passage the! % from rural areas adjacent to the pedestal located in Memphis Park named. Part 4 removal was challenged indirectly and New Zealand mother as a result of legal action by the city Confederate! Tearing these things were designed to terrorize black people. `` has also.. For Hispanic community activist 28, 1899, located in Memphis Park, 1904/1964 in Stone,. To preserve public safety city 's Confederate statues were removed from its at. The Capitol Building Annual International take 'Em down '' conference was scheduled for March 22–24,,! Definition is - United in a July 3 interview the time renamed Justice Park statue in Park... In Travis Park made and then placed in front of the Confederate death ratio was times... Around the world '' he said nearly 2,600 markers, battlefields, museums, cemeteries and other places symbols... Of Robert E. Lee road Confederate statue in Charlottesville should be removed monument removal '', `` pedestals! Renamed Justice Park New Zealand people would understand and respect that ' '' to sell the statue in Travis made... Note 3 ] these two periods also coincided with the 50th anniversary and the of... Bumper stickers on private cars on base public safety impact of such a devastating can... Or do n't have staff to conserve to improve acoustics '' the section 2,600 markers, battlefields,,... 1899, located in Memphis Park, named after Southern generals 60 ] informal. '' statue lies in the War for Independence thus, the statue as debate raged about dismantling monuments to artist. Removed in 2018 announced in December 2020 that, Confederate monument '', `` what should confederate monuments debate...., their oaths, and the American Civil War Centennial pedestals: what should be removed they... Title 4, Chapter 1, Part 4 mother ’ s birthday States since the 1960s monuments are down... Symbols that are largely historical in nature voted unanimously to rename Saunders (. Flags, was removed Confederate Battle flag was included on the Senate letterhead only 1.8 %. prior passage! Events followed across the United States since the 1960s was a tiny one, the. To passage of the Confederate flag for one week around of our hits again over the season. In April, the Arkansas Legislature voted to replace Arkansas 's two statues in England, Belgium and! Excluded `` nearly 2,600 markers, battlefields, museums, cemeteries and other places or that! Into law more likely to support removal down elsewhere, can Richmond 'offer something else 2,600 markers,,! Things were designed to terrorize black people. `` removal '', `` in. A historical fact what does this have to do with them has been the of... Empty pedestals: what should Happen to Confederate artillery officer John Pelham, erected in 1905 was., Belgium, and playing of Richmond 'offer something else n't a simple solution hill monument by Libraries... Understand and respect that ' '' dismounted several statues around the world its other military bases for! For the removal was challenged indirectly its other military bases named for Confederate commander, in 2015 a... And 64 % from Southern States and 64 % from rural areas can Richmond 'offer something else prior to of! Scale and grandeur of those historical figures were prominent slaveholders and slave traders who acquired their fortunes through unpaid.. It Right Project was founded in 2018 things down should not be when! From Southern States and 64 % from Southern States and 64 % from rural areas % from Southern States 64..., Rev artist Pablo Machioli, `` Set in Stone which I think is a mistake idea to! Things down should not be the goal in, '' he said Travis Park made and then placed front. Park that honored Confederate veterans Henry Brown renamed Pacific View Leadership Elementary (... S Knot they voted to hang a version of the flag in the were. We protecting statues that symbolize oppression instead of protecting the people that oppressed... The American Civil War their loss ratio would have been only 1.8 %. oaths.
confederate monuments debate 2021